Boutique search · The comparison
Same fee range. Completely different machine behind it. Here's exactly what changes when the person you hired is the person doing the work, and when a big agency is genuinely the better call.
The short answer
A boutique search firm sells depth. A big staffing agency sells scale. Large agencies like Robert Half, TEKsystems, or Insight Global are built to move volume: many open roles per recruiter, layers of account managers between you and the person sourcing, and candidates pulled from databases and job boards. Chasen Talent is built the opposite way: a few searches at a time, run start to finish by the founder, recruiting people who aren't applying anywhere. If the hire is scarce, senior, or company-defining, the boutique model is built for it.
Side by side
| Chasen Talent | Big staffing agencies | |
|---|---|---|
| Who runs your search | The founder, personally. Intake to offer. | A recruiter assigned after the sale, often hired within the last year. |
| Handoffs | Zero. One person, full context, the whole way. | Salesperson → account manager → recruiter → coordinator. Your role's context degrades at every step. |
| Searches per recruiter | A few at a time, by design. Full attention on each. | A long queue of open roles competing for the same recruiter's week. The easiest-to-fill roles win. |
| Recruiter turnover | I own the firm. I'm not leaving your search. | Agency recruiting is one of the highest-turnover jobs in professional services. Recruiters leave mid-search and roles get reassigned cold. |
| Where candidates come from | Direct outreach to people building and selling right now, not on the market. | Internal databases and job-board applicants, often the same active candidates every agency is forwarding. |
| Specialization | Two deep practices: startup engineering, and revenue & go-to-market. That's it. | Every vertical at once: healthcare, legal, admin, finance, IT. Generalists covering markets they don't live in. |
| What your fee funds | The search itself. | Offices, management layers, internal sales teams, and margin targets, then the search. |
| Who you talk to | The person doing the work. Direct line, same day. | An account manager relaying messages to a delivery team you may never meet. |
| Accountability | My name is on every search. Your outcome is my reputation. | Individual quotas and submission targets. Success is measured in volume of activity. |
| Built for | Scarce, senior, company-defining hires where a miss is expensive. | High-volume, contract, and commodity staffing where speed beats precision. |
Why the big-agency model works against you
None of this is about effort. Big-agency recruiters work hard. The model they work inside is what fails scarce, senior searches.
A large agency's fee has to cover real estate, regional management, internal recruiting, sales commissions, and shareholder margin before a dollar touches your search. A boutique's fee is the search.
Big firms hire recruiters in entry-level classes and learn on live searches. The salesperson who won your business is not the person calling candidates about your role.
Agency recruiting consistently ranks among the highest-turnover jobs there is. When your recruiter leaves, your role is reassigned to someone starting from zero, and you usually find out after the pipeline goes quiet.
The nuance you explained on the intake call, why the last hire failed, what the team actually needs, doesn't survive three handoffs. Candidates hear a generic pitch, and the good ones pass.
A recruiter covering legal assistants on Monday and platform engineers on Tuesday can't evaluate either. Specialists know who's actually good, what they earn, and what makes them move.
When recruiters are measured on submissions per week, you get resumes fast and fit slow. When one person's reputation rides on the placement, you get the opposite.
The honest caveat
That's what the big-agency machine is built for, and it's genuinely good at it. But if you're hiring a founding engineer, a staff-level IC, a VP of Engineering, or the revenue leader who'll own your number, you don't need a machine that produces resumes. You need one person who knows the market, carries your full context, and goes directly to people who aren't applying. That's the job I built Chasen Talent to do.
Questions founders ask
A boutique search firm runs a small number of searches with senior, specialized attention, usually with the same person handling the entire search. A big staffing agency runs volume: many open roles per recruiter, multiple handoffs between sales, account management, and delivery teams, and candidates drawn largely from databases and job-board applicants. The boutique model trades scale for depth; the agency model trades depth for scale.
Fees are usually in the same range. The difference is what the fee pays for. At a large agency, part of every fee funds offices, management layers, internal sales teams, and shareholder margins. At a founder-led boutique, the fee funds the search itself, because the person you hired is the person doing the work.
Agency recruiting is consistently one of the highest-turnover jobs in professional services, and large firms hire entry-level recruiters in classes to backfill it. When your recruiter leaves mid-search, your role gets reassigned, context is lost, and the new recruiter starts over. At a founder-led firm the person running your search owns the firm, so that risk doesn't exist.
When you need volume, not precision: dozens of contractors, high-turnover hourly roles, staffing across many cities at once, or payrolling and compliance services. Big agencies are built for that. A boutique is the right call when the hire is scarce, senior, or company-defining and a wrong hire is expensive.
Every search is run personally by Chasen Nick, the founder: intake, sourcing, outreach, screening, and offer. There are no handoffs to junior recruiters or account managers at any point, and only a few searches run at a time so each gets full attention.
What I search
Tell me about the role. If a big agency is genuinely the better fit for it, I'll tell you that on the call.
Book a 30-minute call